There is considerable angst in the Bruce Liberal Party following this week’s preselection for the next Federal Election.
Popular local candidate and Liberal stalwart Anton Vucic had the support and respect of the local party, but it seems that party headquarters had other ideas. Out-of-towner Emanuele Cicchiello clinched the win following an easy ride in the roundtable questioning and the distribution of two amazing brochures to delegates.
One of the more nauseating questions to Cicchiello during the night was: “Why are you such a nice guy?”. He was really quaking in his boots after that one! Vucic, on the other hand, was faced with much tougher questions befitting Q&A or Kerry O’Brien.
It was also clear that Cicchiello’s knowledge of his newfound electorate was not extensive. When asked about his connections to Bruce, he replied: “Well, my wife shops at The Glen.. (Tip O’Neill he clearly aint!) Then things got truly bizarre when Cicchiello struggled to name the sitting Labor Member, Alan Griffin.
Cicchiello, a teacher and Deputy Principal, also should have hired a good proof-reader for his brochures to delegates. Take a deep breath and get ready for the following.
BROCHURE 1:
(1) page 2: spelling error – ‘lead” rather than “led”;
(2) page 3: grammatical error -”second sentence “….to build better future for me, my sister and brother……”;
(3) Page 3: part-time employer Professor John Polsel undergoes a miraculous name change and becomes Professor Richard Teese on page 5 (his CV page) ;
(4) page 4: his wife grew up in “Forrest Hill”, and not Forest Hill, as we know it;
(5) page 5 : “Forrest Hill” again;
(6) page 6 = he strode the international stage as a Young Liberal State President, where he helped “foster international relations between Australia and Vietnam..”
BROCHURE 2:
(1) page 1 : the aspiring Liberal Candidate for Bruce has a large front-cover staged action-photo, showing him campaigning amongst startled traders in the neighbouring seat of Hotham;
(2) page 2 : spelling error “pink bats” – apparently, he has discovered a new specie of bat……;
(3) page 2 : “national parliament….”;
(4) page 3 – “the issues that matter in Bruce…” include “…. supporting traditional family values…” – clearly Bruce is a moral cesspool, according to our Emanuele;
(5) page 4 – lists local Bruce schools including, Waverley Christian College, which sadly for Emanuele, is in Aston;
(6) page 4 – lists “Manufacturing hub in Dandenong South”…… sadly, in his old hunting-ground of Holt;
(7) page 5 – will conduct a stunning campaign via non-existent Bruce “community radio…”;
(8) page 5 – proud picture of the future Federal Candidate posting a letter;
(9) – Bruce voters eagerly await his stories, regaling them of his famous baby-sitting adventures;
(10) – proudly ran as Liberal Holt Candidate in ’07, achieving a -10% 2PP swing, double the state average, clearly impressing the party chiefs with his vote-winning prowess for the ALP;
(11) – rejected by Knox residents in 2005 and 2008 for a seat on Council; not to mention being a failed preselection candidate on 3 prior occasions;
(12) – page 8 – highlights referees from Waverley Golf Club and Waverley Christian College: neither of which are in Bruce;
(13) – page 9 – proud display of a reference from his GP….. reinforcing his heavyweight local support to take on the Labor machine….
(14) – page 11 lists “ethnic” papers: “Chinese Paper” (sic) and “Neos Cosmos” (sic).
Overheard in the car-park at the end of the night was a long-time party veteran, shaking her head, lamenting, “I can’t believe Cicchiello won. There goes Bruce for another three years.”
Of course, the big winner here is Alan Griffin. He won’t be losing any sleep. One wonders why Liberal headquarters so brazenly backed the inferior candidate. I thought they actually wanted to win the seat.
A disgusted State Council Delegate (never wasting my time at these pantomimes again).
Bugger the residents of Bruce. I’m more concerned about the poor kids taught by this bloke! Fingers crossed, he’s not an English teacher…
Tell him to piss off back to his homeland, the last thing Australia needs is another unclean migrant in Parliament.
The best candidate lost. Simple.
Was he or his opponent born in Australia? Perhaps English is a second language.
What clown at party headquarters backed Cicchiello for candidate? He needs a Melways to find the seat of Bruce! I just hope he can read it.
Ciccenlinto is a vice principle ffs
The best candidate lost and lots of my faith I the liberal party has been lost
Anton was a favorite son in Bruce and many hoped he would do well. Reality was that he performed poorly in front of an audience and the other man was more confident and polished. Tory Ted, all we can take from this is you do not understand the politics of preselection and the fact that performance, planning, and recruitment of good supporters are important factors. Grow up
Please leave teacha Manny alone. He tort me english good
I hear that Emanuele has driven through Bruce many times on the way to get his fish and chips. Surely that makes him qualified to represent the good citizens there. God help us Libs.
What a joke is this Candidate? I used to live in Knox. His name is mud there. The rate increases when he was Councillor and Mayor were obscene.
Cant Wait till English On Monday now, i know what your like Mr. Cicchiello
ps im also passing this to the others in the school monday i must go to school fun awaits !
THANK YOU TO GOOGLE TO FOUNDING THIS !!
Of course Mr Cicchiello knows Bruce: he comes to my shop once a month to get his fish and chips!
Thank you, Libs, for Cicchiello.
I WANT A RE-VOTE… ONLY ANTON SHOULD HAVE THE JOB, CICCHIELLO CANT DO IT FOR US, ONLY ANTON !
RE-VOTE NOW PLEASE !!!!!!! I WAS THERE…THE FIX WAS SICKENING
Anton Vucic is clearly the better candidate. When will the Liberal Party wake up to itself?
Plus Anton didn’t insult our intelligence by saying he “watched people’s homes while they were on vacation”, as if that qualified him for high office! The other candidate did though.
I’m Leaving the Libs Party Now….how sad for genuine candidates
I have been a loyal member of the Liberal Party for 20 years and I was there on the night and I was disgusted by what I saw. Vucic was clearly the best candidate and has been the backbone of Bruce for as long as I can remember and this is the way the Party treats a loyal servant?
It’s an absolute disgrace!
Thanks to 104- my job becomes so much easier to hold the seat for Alan!
What odds for Vucic to be drafted? What a mess. What possesses idiots to try and impose factional mates upon an electorate?? Step aside Labor: the Vic Libs take the gold medal in preselection stacking and stupidity.
Local members are overrated.
Particularly members who aren’t private school educated, upper middle class and from the inner east.
How on earth did Emanuele get past the pre-selation vote and let alone win this?! That is beyond me… Those spelling errors are a disgrace for a school principal!
Anton was clearly the best candiate considering he ACTUALLY LIVES IN BRUCE!
WTF happened?!
Ha national parliament… you won’t get there Emanuele, Labor will no doubt keep this to themselves. Liberals don’t stand a chance with this digrace of a teacher… long live Labor!
Wonderful logic from 104. Usually you parachute in a quality candidate not a hack with a record of failure
Gee his brochures appear as bad as Michael Danby’s newsletters.
Me just come here from Italy. Can Mister Emanuele make me good speak English?
Anton Vucic was treated appallingly after serving the Libs in Bruce for 20 years.
Cicchielllo….. What a joke
Cicchiello promoted to Principal by Helen Kroger
http://www.helenkroger.com.au/LatestNews/tabid/82/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/44/School-principal-congratulated-on-Bruce-preselection.aspx
Bozos
So, what are you talking about? The same shit goes on with Labor. No wonder the major Parties ar on the Nose, always putting up useless second rate no-hoppers
There’s no hope for Bruce to win the seat for Libs. Labor it’s your for the next 3 years !
Don’t waste your time with them anymore…… The Libs need you more than you need them, Anton
I am a constituent of Bruce and I am disgusted to read that this Cicchiello guy has been preselected. I am not so sure if I will vote Liberal now.
from also disgusted
just like the clowns from 104 manipulated chisholm two federal seats down the drain.
What a joke, Cicchiello had a lot of local support
The best Lib candidate for Bruce was not even running.
I’ve just read this article. It gives me renewed hope for preselection. After all I’m just as thick and even more poorly educated as this clown so I am a shoe-in for a plumb seat. Having said that, notwithstanding I am a bit dim I’m still much brighter than the average ALP politician.
P.S. I still secretly hate who and what I am
And did Frankie put Cicchiello through the hoops?
To be fair, it wasn’t only morons at 104 who wanted this dud to get up. Helen Kroger’s fingerprints are all over this fiasco too. No wonder she was demoted to number 3. Having a fellow non achieving hack running in Bruce ensures that her vote won’t hold up to get back.
I was a delegate too at the preselection. There was no doubt that the result was predetermined by 104 and their minions. Vucic may have lacked polish but Cicchiello lacked any substance whatsoever. When you compare both candidates overall, including their published literature and Content in their official nomination form, there is no doubt that Vucic was the clear winner. His materials and speech displayed excellent knowledge of Bruce and relevant policies and issues. Cicchiello’s intellectual contribution to this preselection was non-existent.
You have to wonder how some of these people get preselected. Does he have compromising pictures of someone. Alan Griffin is a first class shit of a human being and a lousy local member. A good, strong Liberal might just oust this seat warmer, but instead the Libs pre-select a fool.
Long may the Liberal Party preselect illiterate half-wits and cretins. Is it any wonder that Victoria is the ALP’s strongest state?
Will the Post by “Trash story” please get a life, and maybe you should Grow up. The only thing trash here is Cicchiello and you know it…..
Chisholm and Bruce down the toilet let’s hope Deakin comes back. At least we can have some credibility in the east.
I knew Alan Griffin was good at organising numbers, I did not know that he was this good. :) :) :)
And how about the white beareded man who looks like Santa – what role did he play in stitiching up the numbers?
I was a delegate that was there on Tuesday night for the pre-selection vote for Bruce.
Anton is no JFK but he was the better candidate and could’ve had a chance of winning this seat for the liberals. He also actually lives in Bruce unlike Cicchiello. Cicchiello had no depth let alone substance. Bruce needs a hard worker such as Anton over that smooth talker Cicchiello.
Cicchiello will more no doubt lose this seat again to the Labor, we would’ve had a chance with Anton.
What about preselecting Towlie from Southpark. He could win. He’s a towel
I think the best thing 104 can do is a re-vote or give it to Anton.
Oh no … he is a Christian
Yes Chris you’re so right, just give it to Anton. 104 get the point. Fixxing is not allowed in Australia !!
ANTON FOR MP, ANTON FOR MP, ANTON FOR MP, ANTON FOR MP, ANTON FOR MP
anton should have this end of story
Copys Ready For Class Mr.Cicchiello, Cant wait for class, i hope you will be there Mr. Cicchiello
Libs get you act togetter and do the right thing for Anton
I just saw Cicchiello harrassing passers-by outside Bruce County Motor Inn. The poor stupid bugger. He doesn’t realise that it’s in Chisholm.
And the Libs bleat about Labor branch stacking and factions. They are no better. Menzies would be spinning in his grave. At least we can be safe in the knowledge that this idiot won’t win the seat.
I am a swinging voter and after reading this story, I cannot vote for this character. How can he represent me when he doesn’t know even the basics of the area? You think we are fools, Liberal Party.
Can we get him in 2016?? He’ll boost our margin by 20%. Moron
I know about Cichiello. He is a fake and a fool. He can talk the legs off a chair. That’s all he’s good for. Thank God I don’t live anywhere near Bruce, but then again, nor does he. What a fraud.
Cicchiello is the perfect example of what we say in Texas. “all straw and no hat.”
I called 5 Libs MP’s about this and not one cares about this. I think this shows it right. Well done Vexnews…… For putting this out there so we know what the libs are really like. No better then labor. Really feel sorry to Anton for when it was a fix and the time and money he put into this….
I too as a delegate last Tuesday night. The description of the night’s events are accurate, and the difference in professionlism and brochure content between the two candidates was significant. Vucic by far exuded the knowledge, political skills and credibility required for a Federal Candidate. Cicchiello’s first brochure was alarmingly light, riddled with spelling and grammatical errors, as correctly outlined in the story. He repeated slabs of his material, and CV, from his official party nomination Form, throughout the first brochure. This suggests lack of any substance as a serious political candidate. The wedding picture was particularly ridiculous, as was the bizzare picture of his mouth open whilst with Minister Kotsiras. His second brochure also contained numerous spelling errors and factual errors, but it was an improvement (well, it had to be, I guess) on the rubbish supplied in the first brochure. No doubt a State MP’s office (or ex-MP) helped him produce his second document. Cicchiello does not have the political savvy to produce a heavyweight document. His second brochure was full of State issues, with very little outlining Federal policy knowledge, or evidence of Bruce community involvement (of which there was just his Dad’s church). He was definitely scrambling to counter Vucic’s impressive documents. But, he still predictably fell short. I voted for Vucic because of his overall package: local business owner, extensive local charity work, impressive political gravitas and proving to me that he understands what is required to win Bruce, and how he was going to do it. Cicchiello comes across as a shallow political operative, who needs to rely on others to carry him through. Sadly, the Party doesn’t allow Candidates to debate one another. I have no doubt that Vucic would have demolished him. I despair for our Party that we have Cicchiello thrust upon us. The local minions who did 104′s bidding deserve the loss which his candidacy will bring.
Bob you can’t be anymore right
It must be galling for Anton to have been betrayed by the Party which he has served loyally for over 20 years. I think he is a 25 year member. I am saddened but also angry for him that morally-bankrupt people from 104 and Admin had to get involved and engineer this result. I am well aware of a very senior Bruce Exec member who proclaimed Cicchiello’s win weeks ago. Shame on all of you. Anton was discarded as piece of irrelevant garbage by those close to him in Bruce, and hideous people like Frank the Baker and Queen Sandra M-M. Labor wins Vic seats because of these vermin.
Look at how successful I am, I aren’t that bright and have got to where I have with my beautiful looking body. Those naughty young men in parliament are always trying to upskirt me.
The article about the Bruce contest is true, i’m sorry to say. I was privy to be shown an email – using his school email account – written by Cicchiello in June when he started the rounds of courting local delegates. I have a copy here……apart from the fact that it was poorly written, again full of poor grammar and spelling mistakes, quite amazing for a teacher and aspiring Candidate. He mis-spelled Waverley twice in his email, “Waverly.” Then he presented a one-sheet CV, again spelling “Waverly.” He clearly has a problem being literate. He really is a joke…….if you can’t get the basics right, how can you expect to be an effective Candidate and MP?? The other Candidate, Vucic, was totally genuine, down to earth and produced outstanding brochures. It was clear that he was very well respected by many in the Bruce community, outside the party. Sadly, idiots in our party, locally and from Admin and 104, made sure that Vucic went down. Thanks to them and Cicchiello’s vacuous intellect and political skills, Labor will retain Bruce easily. I truly shake my head.
ANTON! ANTON! ANTON! ANTON! ANTON! ANTON!
REVOTE! REVOTE! REVOTE! REVOTE! REVOTE!
Hey Cicchiello, we’ve all chipped in to buy a GPS
Have a look at where this dude teaches. They have super record
Hey he is the grubby little bloke from Heildelberg Kebabs.
Please look at the website for where Cicchiello works, he is not even on there, does he really work there??? http://www.lighthouse.vic.edu.au
Cicchiello is definitely third-rate. What a blunder
I warned Anton a month ago that his card was marked, but he said “I can’t believe you.” He’s now learned how brutal some morons are from Admin, especially Frankie and HRH Sandra.
I know Anton Vucic. Anton Vucic is a friend of mine. Mr Cicchiello, you’re no Anton Vucic.
We all know Anton should have it. 104/admin do what is right here, fixxing is not right, do the right thing for Anton after 20 + years with you and the libs.
Just do the Re-vote please
Admin do your work before you lose a lib for over 20+ years. Can’t understand why you do th
Admin do your work before you lose a lib for over 20+ years. Can’t understand why you do this to them and Anton
Cicchiello confided in me that he can count to potato.
I rigged it for Cicchiello because he takes a pride in his appearance
And also…. Manny always brings me cups of tea at State Assembly
Frankie and No More Mercy – what a dynamic duo ( NOT)
This reminds me of how Ron Paul got snubbed out of the republican party. Same thing with Anton
It was Cicchiello’s love of my cakes that made me throw the might of the Liberal Party behind me. Nothing, let alone anyone, even a superior opponent, should stand in between Manny and my pastries!
Great to see my old mate win another preselection for an unsinkable seat.
Manny ith an awethome candidate.
What day is it Honeypot? I get so forgetful counting all these numbers I’m responsible for on my fingers, it can take all day you know.
I wanted Cicchiello to run against me again. I can only win against no hopers like him, now I’m worried the Libs will put a decent candidate to run in Holt and I will finally be found out…..dam, I might actually have to do some work and not just my local media photos stunts.
I might be looking for a gig does it include free chardy?
I am reliably informed that this outcome will generate an ‘Independent Liberal’ candidate in Bruce. The Admin brains trust should remember Joe Dolce’s (Shaddap You Face) lyrics – “Wassa matter you, gotta no respect”!!!
The last time the Libs had a decent candidate in Bruce was when I was the Member.
Cheshire Cat – I’t won’t be Anton. Despite this charade, he has too much respect for the party.
Anton has been slogging it out for the Liberal Party in Bruce for two decades or more and now they squash him for this guy… the mind boggles
Oh just do the re-vote 104, and keep your grubby noses out of it, especially Frank G and the hideous Sandra M.M.
Trust me, cicchielllo is a dud. He lost the preselection vote to Ken Aldred but only got the gig because Admin stripped Aldred of his preselection. The article is totally correct. Cicchiello needed the fix to get over the line. He is as deep as a kiddie’s wading pool. The Bruce FEC has no idea what it’s in for.
I am a member of the Party but will not renew next year. I saw what they did in Chisholm. Contrived a result. To stab in thr back a loyal decent Liberal like Anton, whom I’ve never met but heard good things about, is disgusting. We are no better than Labor. Shame on you, 104 and the evil manipulators on Admin, such as FGand S M-M.
Gidley’s crew of grubs did a deal behind the scenes to shaft Anton in exchange for future votes on a stronger state council ticket…they dont care about Bruce and their future is very limited in the east!
So what was the count?
It was soon to be former Senator Helen Kroger who was Cicchiello’s main local cheerleader. Frank G and the ice-queen Sandra Merc-M also played a huge role in tainting this Convention. They are third-rate people who backed a third-rate Candidate. This is the sad truth in Bruce.
I’m surprised the grubs from 104 haven’t leaked the result. Remember people, state council delegates are meant to be selected at “random”: I bet u they weren’t!
104 deserves rubbish (03 Sep 12, 13:59 hrs) – If you are not renewing your membership why not use your real name? After all, all they can do is suspend you in a Policy Assembly kangaroo courts for 12 months as they did with me in Jun 2003 when I opposed the murderous invasion of Iraq. I got that one correct too.
Soon Howard, Rudd and Gillard will be in The Hague before the war crimes court for Iraq (Howard) and Afghanistan (all three PM’s). Bishop Tutu things the mass killers Bush and Blair should be there too.
Mantach, what did you know and when did you know it? We know you’re out there reading all of this.
In reply to Numbers Please: rest assured that Admin & 104 made sure that Manny had 50.1% before the Convention started. They have no dignity or shame. That’s we have so few seats in Vic
Manny was too good for me in the YL days. But now look who is laughing? That would be me by the way. I am a very important MP.
I can’t believe I followed Manny’s lead and handed in my resignation to the Ted faction. Can I come back?
I agree with Bendigo Liberal: Mantach has Vucic’s blood on his hands…
What the hell is going on in Melbourne? What genuises at 104 and on Admin, and I assume this would include those babbling buffoons Greenstein, Sandra and Damo Mantach, had this brain wave to manipulate the Bruce contest? These people have to go, for the sake of our Party.
Right on, Wannan Lib: these imbicles are the new Three Stooges. Bring back real, decent Liberals to run our Party, not these amateurs engaging in cheap, undergraduate politics. I am honestly sick in the stomach. I was there on Tuesday night. Greenstein strutted like he owned the place; her Ladyship Mercer-Moore expected rose petals to be thrown at her feet as she walked around the Centre.
I received an election flier from one candidate with 13 pages but party rules allow only 10 pages. I did not get to the pre-selection due to last minute problems with scheudle, but did State Director announce teh breach of party rules?
Wannan Lib – Frank Greenstein was a South African refugee over ten years ago in Melbourne Ports. Back then I don’t think he was even an Aussie. These Zionist from SA are single minded dangerous people who abandoned there country after democracy was established. To these creepy South Africans the blacks were treated as the Israelis treat the Palestinians – appallingly.
gidley did it in chisholm as well
he will do anything for a deal
Re the candidates’ preselection brochures, the comment at 18.42 is correct. The offical Rules state that no more than 10 pages can be senbt at any one time, and as per Mantach’s memo to Delegates dated 6 August 2012, it states “The Party takes the breaches of these Rules very seriously.” Past precedent is clear on this. The Breach by Cicchiello ought to have bene disclosed to delegates on the night, by him. It wasn’t. I know because I was a delegate. Mantach has serious questions to answer. Poor Anton – he sent out 9 pages, then 4 and 4; Cicchiello sent out 9 and 13. 13 exceeds 10, which is a clear Breach. This smells of a tainted convention………..
The MP that worked against Anton was Mrs Michael Kroger. Cicchiello even got Chris Pearce, the nobody ex-Aston MP to ring around for him.
Gidley certainly will do ‘anything that is required’ and I mean ANYTHING AT ALL for a deal.
Hey Emanuele phone order for Kenny I’ll have 2 Flake, 2 Potatoe Cake and $3 of Chips. Please make sure you keep your stinky breath of my dinner.
The official Party Rules are quite clear: no more than 10 pages at any time are to be sent by candidates for preselection. I was a delegate. Cicchiello sent out 13 pages on the Thursday before the Convention. A clear Breach. State Director Damian Mantach was duty bound, by solid precedent, to advise delegates at the Convention of a candidate’s Breach. He failed to do this. Looks like Anton never stood a chance.
Yes. Cicchiello breached the rules by sending out 13 pages (the official rules only permit 10). Typical cavalier attitude by Cicchielllo. Mantach was required to disclose the breach to delegates. He failed to do so.
Poor Anton. He never stood a fair chance. How disgusting.
Mr Fifield I know you are very very important and I am still willing to walk around and buy your pies at Sunbeam Cakes.
If Cicchiello breached the rules then why weren’t the delegates advised of this?
Has anyone bothered to raise this with 104?
Shouldn’t there be a re-vote?
I think Mantach will regret the Cicchiello breach cover-up. Anton was never meant to prevail.
The Liberal Party has a long history of duds in Bruce: Sneddon, Aldred, Beale and now Cicchiello.
From the phone calls and interference by “104″ sycphocants and current and an ex-politician suffering from Relevance Deprivation Syndrome, it was clear that the fix was in. Even the State Vice President in charge of one of the round tables declared that he would rule out of order any question that “embarrassed the candidate” or “was to advantage another candidate”. Dorothy Dixer’s only please! They were desperate to get Cicchiello up despite his being a proven electoral failure in Holt (2007) and Knox Council elections (2004 & 2008) which he touted as his experience.
Meanwhile Queen SMM posed a nice little “Dorothy Dixer” and salivated over Cicchiello’s facile answer. Not even a semblance of balance. But will QSMM and her team be able to provide a lot of resources from “104″ as I suspect there will be little local support in the election.
Hope a good Independent Liberal tosses their hat in the ring, as I won’t give Cicchiello my vote.
I also note Cicchiello guaranteed to the convention that he had a very understanding employer who will allow him all the time he needed to campaign. I wonder how the fee paying parents at his school feel about that promise?
Labor has been given the ideal candidate to resoundingly thrash.
For those asking for the result it was 44-60.
Impeach Mantach: he knowingly covered-up a breach from Cicchiello. This is just unbelievable.
Never fear, Mulgrave Mauler, Chicchiello is never going to get an 8+% swing to win Bruce. Bruce will be yet another notch on his belt of defeats -Taylor Ward, Knox City Council 2005; Taylor Ward, Knox City Council 2008; Bayswater preselection; Holt preselection to Ken Aldred; Hollt election after Lib Party HQ refused to endorse Ken….. and soon to be added to that list of woe: Bruce 2012.
Cicchiello needs help. He is semi-literate and can’t even follow Party rules. And the powers-at-be rigged the night for him. What the hell? Bruce is in a shambles.
Victoria can keep Mantach.
The Cicch also lost Ferntree Gully preselection in ’05, too.
Oh you Liberal local branch members are all so jealous and spiteful of the success of others. This result is just the kind of meritocracy we need in politics.
As a long standing eastern suburbs ALP member, can I please ask that the genuises at 104 (is that their collective IQ?) pull the same preselection stunt in Deakin, LaTrobe, Holt and Isaacs. Please.
Manny is such a nice young man.
So the physiotherapist, the pharmacist turned baker and the gambler are in charge of the fix?
Manipulation of the Party is best left the hands of a chiro.
It is clear that the Bruce race was just a grubby, well-oiled sham, from Mantach down. Party members need to take a stand. The Party Constitution allows an Electorate Council to challenge an endorsement if significant new information come to light about a candidate. The vote-rigging and breach by Cicchiello meet this criteria.
Without people like FG and SMM the Party would not have won the last state election. Those criticising them should be ashamed – what have you done for the Party lately?
Cicchiello is an idiot. To produce error-ridden material so blatantly explains his track record of failure. Fancy your main brochure photo being taken in another electorate. Put some adults in charge please.
State Council delegates need to remove Greenstein and mercer-Moore off admin, and fast. As for Mantach, he has tarnished his reputation by hiding Cicchiello’s breach. Tony Snell has a crisis on his hands.
Oops – I turned up to Bruce pre-selection on Wednesday 28th August – that was the original date provided by 104?!
Yes, Confused of Mulgrave; that was example one of Mantach’s competent work. Any you think he will lead us to victory in any seats with a margin of more than 0.001%. If I was Sarah Henderson, I’d be really worried about Mantach running her campaign.
Now I know why there was only one name on the screen displayed by Mantach, prior to voting: “Cicchiello”.
104/admin need to come out and make a press release on this matter now, really all your names are mud like the Lib party. You shamefully stitched up Anton
My God. Can this scandal get any murkier ?
They say I am dishonest and tell lies. I don’t really, as I too sleepy to do that, as I’m always relaxing on Kate’s day bed with a nice cup of herb tea.
What’s the world coming to? Everyone enjoys a stacked preselection
104 come out and say what really happen here, if you dont we will have to take this as what happen and is right, we all know you are looking at this…
Simple question: what where the numbers in Bruce?
Anonski – no one knows. Scrutineers and 104 staff are sworn to secrecy. Heaven forbid a rule being breached. Mantach will launch an immediate Royal Commission. Shame the Cicch’s breach was covered up though
Mantach, We know your the problem, so come out and say why this was a covered up please….
Mantach, Mantach, Mantach, Mantach, Mantach, Mantach, what have you done here, show your cards and start fixxing the mess you made. . . . . . . . . . .
So Over Mantach And His How He Covered Up Many Things. Mantach Should Go. I Will Help You Pack Your Bags At 104
Does Manny have a teenage daughter, as I’m always ‘up’ for giving any young lady a ‘ride’ home?
Dear Anonski – all the matters is that I had the numbers.
i call on the Scrutineers and 104 staff to say what the votes really are, to see if Mantach will “launch an immediate Royal Commission” Mantach your a joke and leave the Libs NOW
YOU HAVE MADE A ERROR MR MANTACH AND THIS ONE WILL COST YOUR JOB WITH THE LIBS
Anton, you should face Mr. or in this case Miss. Mantach over this and if you dont get something good then mantach should leave and yes i will help pack his bags too color……
i was going to vote for libs at the next one but i think im happy with labor…… at lease the cover ups always come out with labor………
The state Director is the paid servant of the people. We just want to know which people?
Calling On Mr. Mantach……. come out from 104 and say what you did like a man not a mouse…
I’m struggling to understand how you all feel that an “Administrative Committee” has any power or influence. Don’t they just do admin work and leave decisions up to the state leaders???
Dear Bruce Liberal, if only you were right. The Admin Committee is like the Politburo. The Prince of Darkness is Frankie Greenstein. His devoted consort is Sandra Mercer-Moore.
We don’t want some smelly, unwashed, illiterate immigrant like him in our great party.
“You know what I’ve noticed, nobody panics when things go according to plan. Even if the plan is horrifying. If tomorrow I tell the press that, like a gangbanger will get shot, or a truckload of soldiers will be blown up, or a candidate in the federal election gets swindled nobody panics, because it’s all part of the plan. But when I say that one little old mayor will die, well then everyone loses their minds.
Get back in your cave, Mercer-Moore
Haven’t seen you yet in Noble Park, Manny. Have you heard of our suburb, Manny?
Stop lying about your record, Cicchiello
looking forward to Mantach lying about why he failed to disclose Cicchiello’s breach…… He’ll cite some 19th century irrelevant English Liberal Party ruling that was written by Gladstone. Liar.
I think Emanuele Cicchiello is that chap who drives one of my garbage trucks in Melbourne. He sings as he works but stinks like Sandra Mercer-Moore’s most unpleasant body.
Mulgrave Mauler – your generalisation about Liberal MHRs for Bruce was wrong with respect to one particular. I, the great Ken Aldred, sometime Member for Henty, sometime Member for Bruce and sometime Member for Deakin, am no dud!
Can someone please direct me to Waverly Gardens? Is it near Forrest Hill?
Why is everyone being so mean to my good mate Manny. It is not like he has done anythink wrong.
Frank Greenstein – is that the one who looks like Santa?
WTF. Scumbag Manny won a preselection?
No. Frankie is a two-faced chameleon. Not one fibre of decency in his body
Leave me alone! I often drive through Bruce to pick up delicious cakes from Frank Greenstein’s cake and pastry emporium. Yummmmmy!
Hopefully Sticks will step aside, in the best interests of the club, for me.
Bruce, like Menzies, is mine!
So what were the numbers? They are beling leaked for every preselection apart from this one…something stinks!
Cakes are yummy – but I prefer ice-cream.
Ice cream! I love ice cream.
How can our great party expect to govern Australia when it cannot organise a proper pre-selection ballot in Bruce? It’s time for Mr Abbott to fix this mess!
Yum yum yum Frankie greenstein bakes the best vanilla slices…. I love them so much
Any news from Politburo poodle Dami Mantach about why he concealed Cicchielllo’s blatant rule breach?
Manny, can you please pick up my dry cleaning, petal?
Frankie and Sandra didn’t tell me that Bruce would require hard work! Damo, report my breach and give it to Anton. As if I want to visit railway stations and the Frankston Market!
Are you sure Mantach and Kroger are not ALP plants? Their stupidity and incompetence have been a godsend to Labor.
Let’s not just whinge about this outrage. Get on the phone to 104 and tell them how you feel!
No, I won’t have that! Mrs Michael Kroger promised me this prize, with help from Frankie, Damo and Sandra!
Better still, let’s wake up Mantach from his afternoon nap and march into 104!
Manny, dear child, where are those pastries from Frank’s emporium? I’m hungry! It’s afternoon tea time……
Enjoying the blowtorch, Mantach?
Re preselection ballot in Bruce.. The best candidate lost.
Libs have now lost my vote..
Is that the sound of a paper shredder coming out of Mantach’s office? Here’s a handy hint. The delete button on your computer doesn’t mean the file is destroyed.
I can’t believe this idiot’s brochures. What kind of Party wants him as a candidate? Schoolboy errors from a school teacher. How ironic.
Hey, how cool is this?? The old VFL Park is in Bruce! Auntie Sandra and Uncle Frankie never told me this!
This is one of he most stupid and ridiculous outcomes since 104 preselected Geoff Shaw
When will 104 fess up to this miscarriage of justice?
Manny, dear, I’m out of milk. Any chance you can pop out and get me a couple of litres? Thank you, petal.
I don’t want tea. I prefer ice cream.
Honeypot please don’t give Fatty anymore ice cream as he is getting so rotund he is having difficulty when he gets on top.
If Mantach has improperly dealt with the breach by the candidate Cicchiello, can a new Convention be called?
My 8.2% margin is now set to increase, perhaps to double figures.
I predict Bruce will be Labor’s safest seat after Cicchiello is let loose, startling the locals, trampling the flora, frightening the fauna…..
Hey, leave me out of this! I wouldn’t want Cicchiello either.
Geoff lets do it again!
Manny, dear, don’t forget to bring me those delicious lamington’s from Uncle Frank’s emporium. Morning tea is almost upon us, petal
There seems to be a lack of esteemed intellectual charismatic talent like me, in our great Party these days.
By looks of all these comments someone from Alan griffins support crew needs to get a life…
Mantach will undoubtedly go down from Rememberance Day 2012 as Cicchiello’s Chihuahua
Cicchiello call me we could make beautiful music together. I do still have Wednesday nights free when I am not entertaining other Gentlemen.
I’m not manning a booth for this fool
_
Who in their right mind could support this bozo at preselection? Heaven help our Party .
Manny, dear, I’m off to the snow this weekend. Please collect my mail for me, petal. You are a good little poodle!
That reminds me, Manny. Get me some pastries, for the long drive, from Frankie’s emporium. But no fattening chocolate eclairs. I have to keep looking regal for a 70 year old. Thanks, petal
Any update on Cicchiello breaching the candidates’ rules re his printed material? Mantach is probably still on his afternoon nap.
What a laugh. Fancy choosing a clown to tackle Griffin. Cicchiello must have some heavy dirt on those that backed him. Why else would they rig it for him?
I wonder why that constituent called me ‘the local town bike’ what on earth did they mean Sammy?
9 days in….. Haven’t seen Manny in Bruce yet…
Cicchiello will need a much stronger deodorant and more personal hygiene if he wants to win over the locals.
Please Liberals, please…. Give us better than this recycled hack. Vucic….. Anyone…. Please step forward
Even I would draw the line at a dumb, showpony hack like Cicchiello. Strewth!
I am the next President of the Victorian Division.
I can’t think of a more vile person than Sandra to be our next State President. Her knowledge of the community doesn’t extend any further than Canterbury.
Keeno. Rorts. Lies.
Phew! No campaign plans for the weekend. Gives me more time to buy those delicious calorie-filled cakes from Frankie’s emporium.
Get this guy off the Lib ticket. I want a reason to vote Liberal. Illiterate lying hacks don’t do it for me. Sorry
Can someone put Vucic back in charge. Cicch is an idiot
Any news from Mantach yet? Has he stirred from his slumber?
If I promise to settle my account with Professor Maku Dong Long can I be the MP for Bruce?
will Vucic take over and remove this low life
Cicchiello you wont win this, so just give it to vucic to win
this is a joke
Did I ever mention that Giidy Up is ministerial material?
Fatty Doyle, trust me – Gidley has talent. The Cicch is an empty shell with a silver tounge, pure and simple.
Giddy Up has almost as much talent as the current member for Bruce.
Fatty maybe I could use Giddy’s silver tongue as an alternative to your little problem?
I am a lifelong Labor voter. My Young Liberal grandson showed me Anton’s 3 brochures, which I compared also with Emanuele’s. I was instantly impressed with Anton’s and would have voted Liberal, for the first time. His local charity work and knowledge of Bruce and its issues swayed me. I arrange a coffee club with 14 other local women, and they also compared both candidates’ brochures and would have voted for Anton. After reading and hearing how Anton was treated by the Party, my vote has been lost. My 14 friends will not be voting for Cicchiello. Well done Liberals: 15 votes lost in one swoop. (Anton, you would have been a great candidate. We’ll shout you a coffee at our club mate!)
Shirley – why is you YL grandson showing his Commo grannie Liberal documents. You are a liar Shirley.
Be careful insulting people, Juliass. I don’t report to you. Believe me or not, I don’t care. Why would I lie? The Libs Lost 15 Bruce votes because of their stupidity.
Shirley – You say you are a life long ALP voters, so whats changed that you may now voter liberal; is labor so bad? Are your 14 friend all robots who do what you say without exception. You are still a liar.
Juliass, not that i owe you an explanation, but I am very disillusioned with Gillard’s Labor. I have seen a lot in my time and don’t like the direction of the country. I saw Anton’s materials and it impressed me. My grandson also told me what a great guy he is. But having read about the shambles in Bruce and the winner Cichiello, it’s made me decide that Libs are no different, sadly. The robots are people who don’t question their beliefs. For a few weeks I did.
Why did David A.s.m.a.r get sacked from C.o.n.r.o.y’s office? I’m waiting for the Ombudsman’s report. Won’t help lady Di’s prospects of running the world’s most dysfunctional will it.
I am too busy for Chichiello who is only a poor teacher.
I am more interested in the wealthy property owners I bedded in Ballarat and look forward to receiving their cheque towards my election campaign in the mail.
Wenchy I heard it on the grapevine that the wealthy property owner from Ballarat had to take a wire brush to hs member to prevent the nasty little itch you gave him.
Boofa, you got it all wrong. It wasn’t one wealthy property owner. It was actually two. We did the bars, then the hotel room for a romp ( not just the plain old one ordinary hotle MPs slept at)but a very upmarket one just suited to my high status life . It was a little far from my destination and I did get caught up in traffic ( of the bedroom variety). But I know that a nice juicy cheque will be in the mail for me.
Mmmmmmm no reporting on comrade Asmar on this site
Hmmmmm I wonder what delights I can consume this morning at Frankie’s emporium…. another excuse to drive through Bruce, too :)
“When it comee to Machiavellian bastardry, the Labor Party are world champions”: Tony Abbott, 12/10/10.
Boy, is he wrong: Mantach, Frankie Greenstein and HRH Sandra M-Moore far exceed Labor’s prowess…..
Shirley – I you are a life
long Labor supporter and you dont like the Liberal who was preselected by a democratic vote then I assume you will still vote Labor along with your 14 friends.
So it no change or status quo for voting the intentions of your 15 votes but this will have little impact on the demise of the federal Labor government. So we agree on something.
Alan Griffin used to employ a later Port Phillip councillor called Julian Hill(late 1990′s). Little Julian would get in the press with pictures saying he was a good local and loved his little daughter but when he ceased being a councillor he disappeared from view completely. It turned out the daughter was from a broken marriage as Julian turned out to be gay or bi-sexual. Poor daughter, she’s got a daddy, a mummy and a daddy/mummy. The little daughter would be about 20 now.
No sign of Manny anywhere in Bruce today……great work, idiot!
Two weekends of campaigning lost by our illustrious candidate, the Cicch. No show by him, to date. No wonder he recorded a -10% result in Holt in 07. Great choice, Frankie G and HRH Sandra MM. Idiots.
Why dont people understand my position?
English the national language in Australia not that Glasgow gibberish Mr Oliver. Go back were you can from which is a Rustbelt former shipyard in Scotland.
The reason British shipyard went bust is the workers were paid to much and the yard could not compete with other nations. Before World War 2 about 80% of all ships were build in Britain.
A business buggered by unions and now they want to do it to the building industry in Australia.
Some heads will have to be rolled after this shambles and embarrassment of a pre-selection process. Rigging this so you can have a puppet?
This isn’t the NSW Labor party, but the Australia Liberal Party. They will pay, oh they will pay!!!!!
Sandra and 104 wanted this but rather wanted the stupid puppet, Emanuele Cicchiello to run so they could still work together, don’t mean around a desk, on the desk, between the sheets!
Children please listen to Nanny and all go back to reading the story Huff and Puff The Premier.
Bad polling news for Ted- maybe they should give Vucic a state seat?
Manny oh manny, when will you even think about starting campaigning?
It is no wonder Premier Doolittle and his team of Bright Sparks would lose 3 seats in the south east, the ones they won from Labor. Just look at their 3 MPs there 1 is so thick they call her Blankety Blanks and the other 2 women drop their knickers for every contributer to their campaign accounts.
“we are searching high, we are searching low, no sign on Bruce of that loser Cicchiello…..”
Anton clearly didn’t even stand a chance! Sandra and 104 had obviously planned that the puppet was going to win regardless how many posts Anton got!
HRH Sandra needs to resign as this is against the democracy of the citizen’s of Bruce! They would’ve done well with Anton not a puppet!
HRH Sandra needs to resign as this is against the democracy of the citizen’s of Bruce! They would’ve done well with Anton not a puppet!
How many puppeteers does Emanuele Cicchiello need? Only two apparently, Sandra and 104! They should’ve ran if they wanted it rigged! They need to lay for this, of the wait the public will already get their revenge. Go Labor, GO!
What a glorious Spring day. No need to waste it trying to win a vote or two in Bruce
Every time the PM goes overseas for foreign policy and trade discussions she rushed back when someone dies. Last week it was because 5 soldiers were killed in Afghanistan and today its because her father died of old age. There is nothing the PM can do by returning early and before the funerals. You have a job to do Prime Minister so get your priorities right.
Manny dear, I’m back from the snow. Don’t forget to bring me some Chinese take away for tonight. Don’t forget the spring rolls and yummy prawn crackers. Thank you, my sweet poodle
Let us know if you need us to find the Cicch: still missing from Bruce, 12 days in…..
I am disgusted with the rigged result here in Bruce. I will not attend the annual dinner or help this clown at any polling booths. Anton would have fought hard to win this seat. Cicchiello is just a hack waiting for things to fall into his lap. You are a disgrace, Mantach and Snell.
Will this move into Parliament help his softy?
Give us an answer about the rigging and cover-up, Mantach! Now !
Manny is a joke.
Emanuele Cicchiello looks like he’s a half caste. Is one of his parents a darkie, or is he just a greasy olived skinned wog? Either way types like that are not in high demand in the current conservative Liberal Party.
The only person who comes out of this debacle with dignity is Anton Vucic. Well done, Anton. You are an inspiration.
Frankie and his fellow manipulators will betray anyone for their own means. Watch out next State Council Franklie. The lobbying against you has started already
Not wrong true liberal. Frankie and Her Majesty Sandra have to be defeated next year
Whilst its always good to see patriots compalin bitterly about douches winning preselections, with all due respect to Anton (yes – he would have made a much better candidate than Manny), does anyone seriously believe that the Liberals are capable of an 8.2% swing in Victoria?
Let Manny chalk up yet another defeat. This will only go to confirm that he is to never be preselected for a winnable seat.
I look forward to crushing any fool that decides to run against me at next year’s State Council AGM.
No More Mercy – I might need your help on the campaign trail when running again for the Lord Mayorship of Melbourne.
Catherine Deveny is a disgusting slag – from an atheist feminist’s perspective.
QandA Watcher – your description of Deveny is very kind.
Q&A is even more of a joke than Question Time in Parliament.
It is funny that the most tightly scripted show on the ABC is the one where the ‘public’ are supposed to be able to ask questions of our overlords. Well it would be funny if it did not make me want to drink domestos.
My dear Fatty, the dearest of all dear fatties. You of course have my support in your righteous quest to maintain the honorific The Rt. Hon. Lord Mayor.
Commissioner (Emeritus) McPerton
McPerton boy have you got fat, I suppose that is what happens when your unemployed and spend the day drinking eastern european whisky.
I still can’t believe that Manny actually won a preselection convention! Fourth time lucky! Even if it is for an unwinnable seat.
You mug, manny!
Does Cicchiello have a teenage daughter, as I’m always up for driving her home.
Sav dear please try the blue pill tonight as I will wear by brief nighty, just this once lets hope for some uplift.
14 days….. no sign of Manny in Bruce yet….
I will gladly replace Manny in Bruce. BTW, where is Bruce?
Eats. Many. Pies.
Mcperton, I wouldn’t have a clue where Bruce is either!
Ouch!! Brutus has given me another little tear in my back passage, but I loved it anyway.
All I know is that Lord Stanley Melbourne Bruce was Rt Hon – much like myself.
Wait till I win this erection and you hear my maiden speech in parliment. I’ll fix you commo lot up.
I always thought the seat of Bruce was named in honour of Australia’s geratest poet.
A great poet – but not a great speller.
Day 16…… no sign of Manny in Bruce…..
I hear that the Cicch offers Griffin “no contest” in Bruce.
When is this freak, Sickello, coming to Bruce????????????
I am the candidate…. You ain’t seen nothing yet..
Cicchiello is now clearly “political roadkill’
Manny was never welcome at the House of Sleaze after he became a Krogerite.
It is not too late 104 – I’m available to resurrect the Party’s campaign in Bruce.
Please a keepa da road kill, I can put my special mamma sauce on it from my luscious crotch and then squeeze it into a pattie in my hairy armpit and my beautiful boy Manny can sell you a lovely kabab from his van in Heildelberg.
Manny will do the impossible and give Alan Griffin an opportunity to increase his margin.
Never a truer word spoken, Bobbafett!
104 fix this before you make the Lib party a joke fully! only a few small steps left to it.
i think the lib party is a joke fully already no small steps needed “new ways”
104 fix it now please
I eagerly await a phone call from 104 – I stand ready to serve.
Manny, oh, Manny, where are you??? 23 days in…… no sighting in Bruce yet??????????????????
Manny – I might need your assistance to win over the Italian vote in Lygon Street. Can I count on your awesome assistance?
Fatty, I will be supporting my old mate, Jack Elliott and his running partner Roy Morgan.
Fatty I am a bit confused as to why you would want to associate with a common little man like Manny?